Unsorted issues > Bug

bugs for doc pages / #5066

MoveBookmark

Summary

open
May 9, 2007
May 9, 2007 / xl
Jun 3, 2008 / stenyak
View previous 5 versions
 

Attached files

No files uploaded
Many comments, especially in the Documentation section in fact are issues (bugs or feature requests).
Why not make it possible to post a bug as child of a doc page?

Use case: A user finds a part of the docs that they dont understand. He posts a bug-comment like "i dont understand the second sentence".
Now a doc maintainer can improve the doc and resolve the bug.

This seems more natural to me than working with comments (which are fine as additional info or discussion).

Issue report

Minor
Have not tried
 

3 Comments

pixtur

May 10, 2007
good hint...
We have a similar problem here. I think we need two options for this:
  1. List related pages from wiki linking (this will really be a good feature and we need it anyway).
  2. With 1. we could provide a feature like "Turn Comment into task" which would hold the original Task in some form of wiki like ala. "originally from yxz:" and the actual comment as description.

xl

May 10, 2007
interesting!
Of course backlinks will bring us nice and sexy benefits! (Memo to me: Fix thougts about Linking and Relationships).
Why would you have the process like 1. write a comment and 2. turn comment into task, and not have a bug-comment (that is displayed in comments) in the first place?

pixtur

May 14, 2007
Bug-Comment
Somehow the bug comment sounds a little bit awkward to me. The whole task think (tasks becoming documentation etc.) is already confusing most users. I would rather have an Action (turning a comment into a task) than a new Type.



 
 

Comment / Update